Weekly Blog by Philip King, CEO of the ICM - 'Making the headlines'

Notwithstanding the Chancellor’s Autumn statement, and the undoubted noise that will follow, I’d instead like to reflect on a couple of reports I've read recently.

 

The first is the SME Finance Monitor (Q3 – 2012) produced for BIS that was published last week. I was struck by a couple of things. Only 46% of SMEs were aware of any of the Business Finance Taskforce initiatives with 22% aware of the Enterprise Finance Guarantee Scheme, 18% aware of the National Loan Guarantee Scheme, and 21% aware of the network of business mentors. Given the amount of publicity and airtime generated during their launch in 2010, these statistics are disappointing.  Even more interesting was the lack of confidence SMEs have in availability of finance.  Overall, only 33% were confident that their bank would agree to their request for finance (the lowest level seen in the six surveys to date), and yet the outcomes are markedly better.  The success rates for renewal applications are c90%, compared to 53% who were confident ahead of the application and, for new applications, the success rates are c56% against a confidence level of 21%.  Both of these aspects show how much more needs to be done in raising awareness.

 

The second is a report written by Duncan Cheatle, who I've met through my involvement on the Board of the Start-Up Loans Company.  Duncan is CEO of Prelude Group and has authored; 'The Unsung Heroes of Business'.  This report tells the story of seven entrepreneurial businesses and analyses their tax accounts.  It shares the views of their owners about taxation, their attitude to it, and their recognition of the value they add to the economy and society through the contributions of their businesses.  The foreword talks about ‘the perpetuated myth that successful business owners are the sole and selfish beneficiaries of the fruits of their business's output’ and delivers the message ‘that we need to do all that we can to encourage and support the relatively small cohort of business innovators who drive value into our economy and make such a significant and mostly overlooked contribution to public finances in the UK.

 

It's a refreshing read at a time when Starbucks, Amazon, Google and others are in the headlines for all the wrong tax reasons.

Weekly Blog by Philip King, CEO of the ICM - 'Merlin loses its sparkle'

Vince Cable has apparently, and allegedly, admitted that Project Merlin has failed. The Merlin agreement with the major banks guaranteed that lending to small businesses would increase to £76bn in 2011 but his acknowledgement that 'new mechanisms' would have to be considered is a tacit recognition that Merlin hasn't worked. The Chancellor's announcement last week of his 'credit easing' plan of a new credit line for business is further evidence.

As I said at the time, the idea that commercial banks could be 'forced' (as some commentators described it) to lend seemed farfetched at best. Commercial banks have a responsibility to ensure that their lending risks are justified and their lending policies are sound. We've all seen spectator examples in the press of where they may have got it wrong but receiving much less publicity are the numerous cases where they've declined to lend and have been right to do so.

I won't pretend to fully understand the concept of 'credit easing', the detail of which has yet to be made clear, but Phil Orford, the Chief executive of the Forum of Private Business asked three very sensible questions in a recent blog about a scheme which it would appear would require Treasury officials, or officials of an agency specifically appointed for the task, to have a start making judgments on lending taxpayers' money to private sector firms:

• How will they decide which companies deserve a loan from the taxpayer?


• How will the money be channeled to the businesses that need it?


• If these businesses are safe bets, why aren't private lenders already lending to them?

All will become clear in due course and I'll be fascinated to see exactly how it will work.

The other issue that needs to be addressed is how to encourage those business with outstanding debtors to use best practice in credit management to release that money and therefore reduce their external cash requirements. It might even save them having to look for working capital funding at all, but more of that next week by which time I'll have met with two MPs - one Conservative and one Labour - and discussed such matters.