Weekly Blog by Philip King, CEO of the ICM - 'Reading, writing and credit management'

Back in February the government announced a new draft National Curriculum for England that would see financial education embedded in both mathematics and in citizenship education, making financial capability a statutory part of the curriculum for the first time. The draft programme of study for citizenship would include the functions and uses of money, the importance of personal budgeting, money management and a range of financial products and services in Key Stage 3, and wages, taxes, credit, debt, financial risk and a range of more sophisticated financial products and services in Key Stage 4.

 

This week, following a period of consultation, Michael Gove published the revised Curriculum and the financial education has been further strengthened by the inclusion of 'risk management' into Key Stage 3 and 'income and expenditure, credit and debt, insurance, savings, pensions' at Key Stage 4. Recognition is due to pfeg for its work in pushing for this enhanced content.

 

Providing education that allows children to leave school with financial literacy can only bode well for the credit profession in the years ahead if it means consumers are more financially aware. None of us wants to see people in financial difficulty through ignorance because they weren't sufficiently aware or informed.

 

In my blog last week I called for the OFT to ensure that affordability tests were genuinely being carried out by payday lenders to avoid the vulnerable being caught in a vortex of indebtedness. An interesting discussion has unfolded in response on the ICM Credit Community LinkedIn group (you can find it here) I don't agree with all the comments - simply outlawing payday lending could carry serious unintended consequences involving a growth in back street loan sharks, for example - but action in the short term is needed and, for the longer term, education will also play its part. Now we need to make sure teachers are provided with adequate tools to deliver the proposed curriculum content.

Guest blog by Debbie Tuckwood, Director of Operational Strategy, Institute of Credit Management – ‘Education that sticks’

In my view many miss opportunities because they overlook people.  It’s easy to focus on process improvement and new technology for dramatic savings.  After all people development takes time and investment - both in short supply.  It’s tempting to run token training though hardly surprising when there’s limited long-term benefits.  Deep down most know that without effective people change is difficult, however is people development really achievable given cut backs in training teams and budgets?

I believe it is, given the right strategy and support.  Look at the Institute’s corporate membership scheme for large teams which involves all.  It’s set up to help secure budgets and regular support from an education specialist (20 – 30% discounts help too).  If you focus then on moving 10% through qualification programmes, whether linked to own training or an external provider, you build skills and the appetite for learning.  After all, isn’t people development more about longer cultural change and ‘education that sticks’?

Weekly Blog by Philip King, CEO of the ICM -'Directors must take responsibility for their actions'

I received the report from the House of Commons Business, Innovation and Skills Committee on The Insolvency Service (Sixth Report of Session 2012/2013) recently. In more everyday parlance, this was the report from the Select Committee that met last October and heard evidence from the Insolvency Service, R3, the Insolvency Regulatory Bodies and others. One of the comments in our submission has been somewhat over-stated,  and our words used out of context, but I am particularly pleased at the inclusion of another reference which says: 'The Institute of Credit Management summarised the concerns of many of those who submitted evidence to us when they commented: "We would be greatly concerned if the reductions in budget [of the Insolvency Service] resulted in a degradation or reduction of Disqualification Unit activity. We believe any such dilution of activity would send entirely the wrong message to delinquent directors at a time when corporate insolvencies are likely to increase".'

 

In connection with the disqualification of directors, the report points out that 'disqualifications have halved over the last couple of years………whilst the number of directors disqualified each year has remained relatively stable over the past decade (approximately 1,200 a year), the number of cases of misconduct identified by Insolvency Practitioners in the same period has risen from 3,539 to 5,401…..the disqualification rate has fallen from 45% in 2002-03 to just 21% in 2011-12.'

 

It is widely accepted that the UK is one of the easiest countries in which to start a business, and that's good, but business owners need to show some responsibility in return for the 'veil of incorporation' which limited company status affords them. If a company can be formed with £1 issued capital and the directors have no personal liability, there have to be consequences if they are found to be guilty of misconduct that leaves their creditors out of pocket. Insolvency Practitioners are required to submit a return identifying where they believe misconduct to have occurred and they have the right to expect their report to be acted upon. Currently only 20% of reports are taken forward to disqualification and that's not good enough so I'm delighted that the Report recommends 'that the Department provides the Insolvency Service with sufficient, and if necessary, additional funding to disqualify or sanction all directors who have been found guilty of misconduct.'

 

Let's encourage entrepreneurship and initiative but let's not turn a blind eye on sharp practice that leaves suppliers with bad debts and impacts negatively on their business and the wider economy. I happen to believe there should be a minimum amount of issued capital required to form a limited company so that directors and business owners take their responsibility more seriously but I'll save that argument for another day. In the meantime, let's hope the Select Committee's recommendation is fulfilled. It definitely needs to be.

Weekly Blog by Philip King, CEO of the ICM - 'That was the week that was!'

Firstly, we had the ICM British Credit Awards at the Park Lane, London Hilton on Wednesday last and, from all the feedback I've received so far, it was our best awards event yet, and one of the best the industry has ever seen. Over and above the joy of celebrating with all those who were short-listed for awards, and particularly with the winners, the evening was a triumph with exceptional entertainment from The Three Waiters, and superb hosting by Martin Bayfield. It was great to spend a night in the company of colleagues from across the industry and a reminder of what organisations like the ICM do so well.

 

Secondly, on Thursday, Michael Gove - the Education Minister - announced that the new draft National Curriculum for England will see financial education embedded in both mathematics and in citizenship education, making financial capability a statutory part of the curriculum for the first time ever.

 

Specifically, the new programme of study for Citizenship includes the functions and uses of money, the importance of personal budgeting, money management and a range of financial products and services in Key Stage 3, and wages, taxes, credit, debt, financial risk and a range of more sophisticated financial products and services in Key Stage 4.

 

This announcement follows a prolonged pfeg (Personal Finance Education Group) campaign supported by the All Parliamentary Group on Financial Education (chaired by my local MP, Justin Tomlinson) and by hundreds of MPs, teachers, parents, and professional bodies including the ICM. It is a triumph for pfeg which coincidentally was the chosen charity for our Awards Dinner and will benefit from the many financial pledges made on the night in its mission to support education providers in giving children and young people the skills, knowledge and confidence to manage money.

 

As I write these words, more pledge cards are still being received so we do not have a final figure of commitments made but, from our work with pfeg in recent years, I am confident that it will all be put to good use and will help to ensure that the next generation is better equipped to deal with personal finance and debt than the current generation.

 

On that subject, the ICM Think Tank this week focused on the role of the advice sector, and particularly the work of StepChange Debt Charity that has been helping people break free from problem debt for 20 years. It was useful for the group of senior executives from across the credit industry to learn more about the charity's mission and work, and to discuss the role of the advice sector and its relationships with the creditor community.

 

Finally, it was good to see the publication by the Insolvency Service of its Debt Management Plan Protocol which aims to protect and promote the needs and best interests of consumers who take out DMPs. In particular, it should help to ensure there is a greater level of consistency and transparency and weed out some of the unscrupulous operators who are conspiring to give the sector a bad name.

 

All in all a good week then!

 

Weekly Blog by Philip King, CEO of the ICM - Giving credit to the beautiful game'

As I write these words, the Chancellor has yet to start his budget statement and - in any event - I wanted to write about something unrelated to credit or business this week. It's rare that I do so and I therefore ask you to indulge me.

I was at White Hart Lane on Saturday evening when Fabrice Muamba suffered a heart attack on the pitch during Tottenham's FA Cup quarter final against Bolton. Those of you who attend football matches will know that emotion and vitriol can run high and sympathy for opposition players when they need treatment on the pitch can be in short supply. These though were not normal circumstances.

It took almost no time for the crowd to appreciate the significance and seriousness of what was happening before their eyes, and 36,000 people were united in willing what were obviously frantic attempts to save the player's life to succeed. The almost spontaneous chanting of Fabrice's name, accompanied by sustained applause, were begging him to respond to the expert attention he was receiving on the pitch, and football was now the last thing on anyone's mind. When the announcement was made that the game had been abandoned, I heard no complaints or dissenting voices and - as has been widely reported - the decision was met with further applause acknowledging that this was the right thing to do.

As the stadium emptied, people talked in hushed tones. At the local station, the staff and network were surprised by the passenger surge arriving almost an hour earlier than expected but nobody moaned at the long wait for the first train, nor at the fact that it was only made up of four rather than the usual post-match eight carriages meaning the majority couldn't get on, and nor that they would have to wait another 15 minutes for the next train to arrive.

The shock of the events they had witnessed minutes earlier had created a surreal reverential atmosphere among people who couldn't believe what they had experienced and were desperately hoping against hope that they wouldn't hear even worse news before they got home.

Of course, we've all been delighted by the ever more encouraging news as this week has unfolded and hope and pray that Muamba's recovery continues and his condition improves. I never want to go through another experience like this but I do feel privileged and proud to have borne witness to such an outpouring of sympathy, respect and unity. Because there is such an appetite for bad news and the reporting of awful behaviour by minorities, it is sometimes refreshing and consoling to get a reminder of the intrinsic goodness of the majority of the population.